Temperature was warmer 1,100 years ago than it is today

Yesterday I posted about an archeological find showing that northwest Canada has been warmer than today. 

Today, an alert reader sent me a study in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) that confirms my suspicions. I will paraphrase portions of that study here.

The study, entitled “Abrupt Holocene climate change as an important factor for human migration in West Greenland,” reconstructed temperature records over the past 5,600 years based on lake sediments in West Greenland. It found that major temperature changes in the past 4,500 years occurred abruptly (within decades), and were coeval in timing with the settlement and abandonment of the Saqqaq, Dorset, and Norse cultures. This suggests that abrupt temperature changes profoundly impacted civilization in the region.

Kangerlussuaq location

Kangerlussuaq lake water temperatures cooled by approximately 4 °C between 5,600 and 5,000 years ago, followed by warming of approximately 5.5 °C that culminated some 3,200 to 3,000 years ago, Then came another sharp temperature drop of approximately 5 °C by 2,800 years ago.

Analyses of lake sediments indicate peak warmth between 4,000 and 3,000 years ago followed by glacial cooling about 3,000 years ago. GISP2 (Greenland Ice Sheet Project 2) ice core results from Summit depict similar trends for millennial-scale.

The large cooling event centered at 2,000 years ago (lake water temperatures dropped by 2–3 °C) corresponds to the greatest glacial advance of inland ice near Kangerlussuaq. The study also found a cooling trend from 3,000–2,800 years ago, and another cold interval from 2,200–1,800 years ago

Arriving in Greenland about. 4,500 years ago, the Saqqaq would have experienced an interval of warmth. They survived transient episodes of warming and cooling, especially between 4,100–3,400 years ago. A cooler interval at about 3,400 years ago. coincides with a contraction in the Saqqaq population and a shift from subarctic to arctic conditions in the Disko Bugt region.

The Saqqaq departure from Sisimiut ca. 2,800 years ago is coincident with the culmination of a pronounced cooling trend (approximately 4 °C in 200 years).

The cooling during this climate transition was no more abrupt than the cooling during the previous approximately 1,500 years of Saqqaq occupation and suggests that the magnitude was more important than the rate of change to the Saqqaq abandonment of the region.

The Dorset disappearance may not be directly related to the intense warming from ca. 2,000–1,800 y B.P. Perhaps their disappearance is related
to a particularly cold interval beginning ca. 2,200 years ago and centered at about 2,000 years ago.

The study also revealed a warming period from about 1,100 to 850 years before present coincident with Norse migration to Greenland.

Then began an abrupt temperature decline (4 °C in approximately 80 years) with persistent cooler temperatures until approximately 630 years ago. This had an adverse effect on Norse farmers in West Greenland and likely contributed to the abandonment of the Norse settlement near Nuuk about 650 years ago.

Interestingly, temperature variations in West Greenland display an antiphased relationship to temperature changes in Ireland over hundreds to thousands of years, resembling the multidecadal temperature seesaw associated with the North Atlantic Oscillation.

I rather doubt that these drastic temperature changes in Greenland all came about because some farmer in Croatia burned too much fossil fuel in his tractor.

As far as I’m concerned, this study proves that the human-caused global warming hype is a total fraud.

Link: http://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/108/24/9765.full.pdf

Thanks to John of Cloverdale, WA, Australia, for this link

This ties in with yesterday’s post

10 thoughts on “Temperature was warmer 1,100 years ago than it is today”

  1. all we need is time to prove just how wrong the agw claims are
    and thats exactly why theyre trying to push their agenda and laws like its urgent life n death
    there may well be death, as when people wake up to the worldgreatest con some of them will be of less than happy outlook,,and may go looking for those that altered/ruined so many lives so abruptly for no real reason.

  2. Quote:

    Interestingly, temperature variations in West Greenland display an antiphased relationship to temperature changes in Ireland over hundreds to thousands of years, resembling the multidecadal temperature seesaw associated with the North Atlantic Oscillation.

    The multidecadal temperature seesaw associated with the North Atlantic Oscillation is also neatly tied to period of the Solar Minimum

  3. This a very good article giving relevant data and logical conclusions. Hopefully some of my warmest friends will be willing to read it. I intend to forward it around.

  4. https://www.livescience.com/39819-ancient-forest-thaws.html

    “An ancient forest has thawed from under a melting glacier in Alaska and is now exposed to the world for the first time in more than 1,000 years.”

    Of course it couldn’t possibly have been significantly hotter when the forest grew there before the glacier buried it – this must be the work of deniers paid by big oil to place the fake trees there when no-one is looking !

  5. A study of Barents Sea temperature variability finds that it follows the AMO and the Gulf Stream, and predicts cooling for 30 years:

    The Barents Sea temperature variability, 1900- 2100

    Harald Yndestad,
    NTNU Ålesund 23.06.2016

    North Atlantic Water controls the climate of the northern part of Europe. The water current passes the Faroe-Shetland Channel and into the Norwegian Sea and continues north with a minor inflow to the Barents Sea. In the Barents Sea Kola section the water temperature has been monitored since 1900 and now represents an indicator of Arctic climate, expected Barents Sea biomass growth and expected economy growth along the Norwegian coastline.
    The Barents Sea temperature has grown the last 30 years to a level, far above historical records. The purpose of this study is to investigate new trends in the Barents Sea temperature variability. Will the Barents Sea temperature continue to grow, or will the temperature turn into a new cold period. The results show that the temperature in the Barents Sea most likely has reached a turning point and we may expect a temperature reduction period for the next 30 years.
    A possible 30-year long temperature reduction in the Barents Sea will introduce a colder climate in North-Europe and influence the marine ecosystem in the Norwegian Sea and the Barents Sea. This will have a dramatic effect on the marine industry, the maritime industry, the fish farm industry and the economy on the Norwegian coastline.

    NTNU in Ålesund, Postboks 1517, NO-6025 Ålesund, Norway http://www.ntnu.edu/alesund


Comments are closed.